Menyanthes Trifoliata appears in 11 of the 13 classic books on Similia. Each was written to do a different job — here is what each adds on this remedy, with the opening of its entry.
- Allen HC — The keynotes that separate this remedy from its nearest neighbours.
“Buck Bean. (Genitanaceae.) Complaints from abuse of Cinchona and Quinine. Fevers, in which the cold stage predominates; coldness felt most acutely in abdomen and legs. Headache: pressing in vertex from above downwards, > during hard pressure with hand (Ver.); as of a heavy weight pressing on the head at every step…”
- Allen TF — The raw proving record — symptoms as the provers reported them, unedited.
“Menyanthes, trifoliata, Linn. Natural order , Gentianaceæ. Common names , Buck-bean, Bitterklee. Preparation , Tincture of whole plant. Authorities. (Hahnemann. Mat. Med. Pura, 5, 15). Emotional. (With increase of the heat, delirium, and small, rapid, irritable pulse), 12 . [In a intermittent fever. -Hahnemann.] Quiet…”
- Boger (GA) — Which general headings this remedy belongs under — the analytical scaffolding.
“COLDNESS, Partial COMPRESSION, squeezing, pinching, as of a vise, cap, etc. (Comp. Cramp.) LYING, Agg. PRESSURE, Amel.; Lying on painful or affected side, etc., Amel. VERTEX”
- Boger (Syn) — Generals and modalities in a short analytical portrait rather than a symptom list.
“Circulation. Motor nerves. Vertex. Walking. Rest. Malaria. Ascending. Quinine. Hard pressure. Twilight. Laying on hands. Icy coldness of prominent, single or affected parts; nose (Ap. Med.), ears, fingers, knees, abdomen, etc.; at night (Pho.). Visible jerks or twitches. Vertex; heavy pressure on; pains, < stooping…”
- Clarke — The widest entry — sources, provings, clinical uses, relationships and antidotes in one place.
“trifoliata. Buck-bean. Bitterklee. N. O. Gentianaceæ. Tincture of whole plant. Amaurosis / Chest, affections of / Cramps / Fidgets / Headache, pressive / Heart, pains in / Intermittent fever / Jerkings / Paralysis The Buck-bean (or "Bog-bean," as it is also called in Ireland and in Lincolnshire) is a water plant, and…”
- Hering — Graded symptoms, each weighted by how often provers and practice confirmed it.
“Buck Bean ; Bitterklee. Gentianaceæ. A perennial which grows in boggy places, indigenous to America, Europe and Northern Asia. It blossoms in May and June ; flowers rose colored or whitish. The tincture is made from the fresh plant just coming into bloom. Introduced by Hahnemann and proved by himself and his provers…”
- Lippe (KN) — Only the symptoms Lippe considered reliable enough to prescribe on.
“Visible, but painless twitching of the muscles. Pinching and stinging in the limbs and joints. Rheumatic pains in the extremities. Great debility often accompanied by chilliness. Inclination to shed tears. Intermittent fever with coldness in the abdomen. Heat in the face, with cold hands and feet. Heat without thirst…”
- Lippe (MM) — The strict Hahnemannian reading — the symptom picture without clinical interpretation.
“Sad, weeping mood. Taciturn and self reflecting. Anxiety about the heart, as if something evil were going to happen. Continuous heaviness of the head. Pressing or compressing headache, with the sensation when ascending as if a heavy weight pressed on the head, relieved by pressing the head with the hands. Pressing…”
- Lippe (Red) — Keynotes with the most-trusted ones marked as red-line symptoms.
“Common name: buck bean. This remedy is indicated in malarial disorders, when the coldness predominates (Bl.). Great debility, often accompanied by chilliness. THE HANDS AND FEET ARE ICY COLD DURING CHILL (Aur., Phos., Verat.) (K.). Intermittent fever, with coldness in the abdomen. Heat in the face, with cold hands and…”
- Nash — The comparisons — the remedy set beside the ones it is most often confused with.
“Icy coldness of hands and feet with warmth of the rest of the body (intermittents).”
